The short version
- In May 2026 the US Supreme Court ruled 9-0 that federal transportation law does not block state-law claims that a freight broker negligently selected an unsafe trucking company.
- Brokers had leaned on that federal shield for years. It is gone.
- Legal commentary since has been direct that the same shield is no longer available to shippers for claims tied to broker-arranged transportation.
- The Court was equally clear this is not automatic liability. A party that chose a reputable carrier and can show how should be able to defend a claim.
- Which makes the operative question a documentation question: who picked the truck, what did they check, and is any of it written down?
What actually happened
The case is Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. Justice Barrett wrote for a unanimous Court.
The legal mechanism is worth two paragraphs, because the shape of it explains why the outcome is durable rather than a technicality.
For decades, a federal statute has stopped states from regulating trucking prices, routes, and services. The purpose was economic: keep fifty states from re-regulating a deregulated national industry. Brokers argued — successfully, in several courts — that a state lawsuit claiming they picked a bad carrier was effectively a state rule about their service, and therefore blocked by federal law.
But the same statute contains an exception preserving each state's authority over motor vehicle safety. The Court held that a claim about negligently selecting an unsafe carrier concerns motor vehicle safety, and so falls inside that exception. In Justice Barrett's framing, a claim is about motor vehicles if it concerns the trucks used to move the goods.
That reasoning is hard to route around. The exception is in the statute, and the Court read it plainly.
What it means practically: if freight moves on an unsafe carrier and someone is hurt, a claim that the broker should not have chosen that carrier now proceeds in state court on its merits, rather than being dismissed on federal grounds.
Why this reaches the company shipping, not just the broker
The instinct is to file this as a broker problem. That is the narrower read, for two reasons.
The federal shield was never shipper-specific. Shippers had invoked the same preemption argument for claims connected to broker-arranged transportation. Legal analysis published since the decision has been explicit that shippers can no longer rely on it either.
The question the ruling puts in play is about the decision, not the job title. Negligent selection asks whether choosing this carrier was reasonable given what was knowable. That question lands wherever the choosing happened. If your company selects carriers directly, it is squarely yours. If a broker selects them, you are the party who chose the broker, and increasingly the party expected to have set standards for how it chooses.
None of which means shippers are now liable for accidents. It means one specific defense closed, and the substitute for it is evidence of reasonable care.
The thing to internalize: the defense is a file
The most useful part of the decision, from a shipper's point of view, is a concurrence rather than the holding. Justice Kavanaugh observed that this ruling should not produce blanket liability — parties acting reasonably, who selected reputable carriers, should be able to defend these suits successfully.
Read that as a specification.
"Acting reasonably" is not a state of mind, it is a record. Carrier safety data is public. Operating authority is public. Insurance is verifiable. If that information was available and nobody looked, reasonableness gets difficult to establish. If it was checked and recorded, you have something to point at.
The information a defensible file contains is not exotic:
- Operating authority — that the carrier is legally permitted to haul what you gave it
- Insurance — coverage limits, confirmed with the insurer or a verified certificate, not a PDF emailed by the carrier
- Safety record — the carrier's public inspection and out-of-service history, and where it sits against national averages
- Specialist qualifications where the freight requires them — hazmat registration, safety permits, driver endorsements
- When you checked, and who checked it — a dated record, refreshed on a schedule rather than at onboarding and never again
The last item is the one that gets skipped, and it is the one that turns the first four into a defense.
What changes on Monday morning
Four things, none of which require a project.
Find out who is choosing your carriers. In a lot of mid-sized companies the honest answer is "whoever answered the phone when we needed a truck." That is now worth knowing deliberately rather than discovering later.
Ask your broker or provider how they qualify carriers, and ask for it in writing. The answer is diagnostic on its own. A provider with a documented standard will send you the standard. A provider without one will send reassurance.
Look at your contracts. Legal commentary since the decision has converged on the same recommendations: state carrier vetting standards explicitly, require verified insurance minimums, exclude carriers with poor safety ratings, and keep audit rights so compliance can be checked rather than assumed. Indemnification language that was boilerplate is now load-bearing.
Treat your highest-risk freight first. Regulated and hazardous material is the obvious starting point, because that is where an incident is most severe and where carrier qualification requirements are most specific. If you ship regulated product, the duties that sit with you as the shipper are the companion piece to this one.
The honest version of the trade-off
Doing this properly is real work, and it is not work that produces a visible return. Nobody congratulates a transportation team for a carrier file.
It is also the kind of work that gets deferred indefinitely in a company where transportation is one of several things a small team handles. The freight moved, the customer got the product, and the file that would have mattered was never opened.
That is the actual reason this becomes a managed transportation conversation rather than a policy conversation. Not because a shipper cannot do it — because in most mid-sized companies, doing it consistently, on every load, and keeping the record current, requires someone whose job it is.
Where Land-Link fits
We qualify and document the carriers that move our clients' freight, and we keep doing it rather than doing it once. That covers authority, insurance verification, safety history, and — on regulated freight — the registrations, permits, and driver qualifications the specific material and quantity require.
The parts of compliance that are legally yours stay yours. What changes is that the transportation side has an owner, working alongside your team, and the record exists before anyone asks for it.
If you cannot currently answer "how was the carrier on that load selected, and what was verified," that is the conversation, and it is a short one.
Frequently asked questions
What did the Supreme Court decide in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II? In May 2026 the Court held, unanimously, that federal transportation law does not block state-law claims alleging a freight broker negligently selected an unsafe trucking company. Federal law stops states from regulating trucking prices, routes and services, but it contains an exception preserving each state's authority over motor vehicle safety. The Court held that a negligent-selection claim falls inside that exception, so such claims now proceed in state court on their merits rather than being dismissed on federal grounds.
What is negligent selection of a carrier? Negligent selection is a claim that the party who chose a trucking company failed to take reasonable care in choosing it — for example by engaging a carrier whose public safety record, operating authority or insurance status should have disqualified it. The question is whether the choice was reasonable given what was knowable at the time, which is why a dated record of what was checked matters more than the outcome of any single load.
Does the FAAAA preempt negligent hiring claims against freight brokers? No longer, following Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II. Brokers had argued successfully in several courts that a state claim about carrier selection was effectively a state rule about their service, and therefore preempted. The Supreme Court held that the statute's safety exception covers these claims. The federal preemption defense against negligent-selection claims is substantially narrower than it was.
Can a shipper be held liable for a carrier's accident? The ruling does not make shippers liable for accidents. What it removes is one specific defense. The federal preemption argument was never broker-specific — shippers had invoked it too for claims connected to broker-arranged transportation — and legal analysis published since the decision has been explicit that it is no longer available to them either. Negligent selection asks whether the choice was reasonable, and that question lands wherever the choosing happened.
Does this ruling create automatic liability? No, and the Court was explicit about it. A concurrence observed that parties acting reasonably, who selected reputable carriers, should be able to defend these suits successfully. The practical reading is that reasonableness is not a state of mind but a record: if safety data, operating authority and insurance were available and nobody looked, reasonableness is hard to establish. If they were checked and the check was recorded, there is something to point at.
How should I vet a freight carrier? A defensible carrier file contains five things: operating authority confirming the carrier is legally permitted to haul what you gave it; insurance coverage limits confirmed with the insurer or a verified certificate rather than a PDF from the carrier; the carrier's public inspection and out-of-service history against national averages; any specialist qualifications the freight requires, such as hazmat registration, safety permits and driver endorsements; and a dated record of when the check was made and by whom, refreshed on a schedule. The last item is the one most often skipped, and it is the one that turns the other four into a defense.
What should I ask my freight broker or 3PL after this ruling? Ask how they qualify carriers, and ask for it in writing. The answer is diagnostic on its own: a provider with a documented standard will send you the standard, and a provider without one will send reassurance. It is also worth reviewing contracts, since legal commentary since the decision has converged on stating carrier vetting standards explicitly, requiring verified insurance minimums, excluding carriers with poor safety ratings, and keeping audit rights.
This article describes a court decision and general industry practice. It is not legal advice. Consult qualified counsel about your own contracts and exposure.
Submit a comment